How to Make my Nana’s Steamed Plum (Christmas) Pudding for the Holidays

Learn how to make an old-fashioned Steamed Christmas Pudding, or Plum Pudding as my nana used to call it, for the holiday season!

Nana's Steamed Christmas Pudding

This month’s Recipe Redux challenge was the following: “Please share one of your favorite food memories and the healthier “redo” of the recipe.” This was an easy decision. Every year my beloved Nana brought her steamed “Plum Pudding” for Thanksgiving and Christmas. It was always my favorite, for reasons I’ll get into later. When I got her recipe card from my mom so I could make it myself, I discovered that the real name for the recipe was, “Steamed Christmas Pudding.”

Nana's Steamed Christmas Pudding recipe card

I wish my Nana was alive so I could ask her why she called this dessert Plum Pudding. After all, there are no plums in the recipe! Maybe someone out there knows the answer to this question? I’m also unclear why it’s called a pudding since it’s really more of a cake. I love this card that Nana typed out for my Mom, and my Mom’s writing to remind her where to find the recipe for hard sauce. Joy of Cooking, of course!

Nana Newell and Dad serving Plum Pudding

When I was preparing to write this post, I asked my husband to check the attic for photo albums from the 1980s since my Nana died in 1989. Five minutes later, god bless him, he brought me an album that had this 1988 photo of Nana being served a piece of her Plum Pudding by my Dad.

How cool is that?

Nana's Steamed Christmas Pudding 13

When they say steamed puddin, they are not kidding. The batter is placed in a metal mold with a cover and steamed for three hours. I was so pleased when the cake slipped out of the mold.

Nana's Christmas Plum Pudding

 

When I steamed the plum pudding, it expanded to lift the cover off a bit so it’s taller than I remember. It’s not as perfect looking as I recall, but it sure tasted good!

Ingredients for Nana's Christmas Plum Pudding

 

The ingredients are really quite simple, and the only changes I made were to substitute 1 cup of whole wheat flour for a cup of the all-purpose flour and to use some canola oil in place of half the butter. Otherwise the recipe is the same as Nana’s.

Nana’s Steamed Plum Pudding

Makes 12 Servings

This old- fashioned Plum Pudding, AKA Christmas Pudding, was a family favorite in the Newell house at the holidays. Cutting back on the butter and adding a bit of whole wheat flour didn’t change the flavor or appeal. Top with a dab of whipped cream or hard sauce and enjoy!

  • 1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 cup whole wheat flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1/3 cup butter
  • 1/4 cup canola oil
  • 1 cup raisins
  • 1 cup molasses
  • 1/2 cup 1% low-fat milk
  • 1/2 cup water

1. Lightly butter a 4-cup pudding mold and set aside.

2. Whisk together the all-purpose flour, whole wheat flour, baking soda, cinnamon, nutmeg, and salt in a large bowl until well combined.

3. Rub the butter and canola oil into the flour mixture (the object is to incorporate the fat into the flour) and stir in the raisins.

4. In a separate bowl, whisk the molasses, milk, and water until well blended. Pour the liquid ingredients over the dry ingredients and stir until just moistened.

5. Pour the batter into the prepared pan and cover. Place in a steaming basket and steam for 3 hours. Allow to cool slightly and unmold the pudding onto a serving platter. Slice and top with whipped cream or hard sauce.

Nutrition Information per Serving: 300 calories, 10g fat (3.5g saturated), 220mg sodium, 51g carbohydrate, 2g fiber, 4g protein, 15% iron

Print Recipe

Nana's Steamed Christmas Pudding

I mentioned earlier in the post that I’d share one of the reasons I loved this dessert when I was a kid. The hard sauce that we enjoyed on top of the Plum Pudding was made with brandy and I felt very grown up eating it. Of course the entire recipe had only one tablespoon of brandy, which explains why my Mom let us eat it. Or, maybe she wanted us to go to bed early on Thanksgiving night!  :)

Mom and Dad eating Nana's Christmas Plum Pudding

Speaking of Mom, I had my parents over for dinner last weekend so they could sample my first attempt at making Nana’s plum pudding. Guess what?  They loved it!

Mold for Nana's Christmas Plum Pudding and Joy of Cooking

If you find a mold to make this Plum Pudding and want to prepare the hard sauce, check out page 775 of the 1975 edition of Joy of Cooking. If you do not own it, simply beat 1/4 cup butter and gradually add 1 cup of powdered sugar until well blended and fluffy. Add 1 tablespoon brandy or rum and a pinch of salt and blend well. Chill thoroughly.

Let me know if you try this recipe, and feel free to share one of your favorite food memories. Happy Thanksgiving!


Tabbouleh with the Works + a Recap of the Whole Grains: Breaking Barriers Conference

Tabbouleh with the Works via MealMakeoverMoms.com/kitchen #WholeGrains #bulgur #vegetarian

This simple tabbouleh side dish is made with bulgur wheat, parsley, chickpeas, dried cranberries, and juicy tomatoes, and it’s bursting with fresh flavors and filling fiber. When you hear the words, “whole grains,” what foods come to mind? Whole wheat bread? Whole wheat pasta? Brown rice? Nutritious whole grains do, in fact, include wheat, but there [more]

Healthy Vegetable Side Dishes for Thanksgiving: A Recipe Roundup

Healthy Thanksgiving Side Dishes from dietitians via MealMakeoverMoms.com/kitchen

If you asked a group of registered dietitians (especially dietitians who also write food blogs) what they’re making for Thanksgiving dinner, chances are, they’d all say … The vegetable side dish. Thats’s what we’d say! Dietitians love vegetables—that’s pretty obvious!—and Thanksgiving is the perfect time of year to show off the freshest produce of the [more]

How to Make Cauliflower Steak + Cauliflower Steaks with White Beans

How to Make Cauliflower Steaks & a recipe for Cauliflower Steaks with White Beans via MealMakeoverMoms.com/kitchen #vegetarian

Have you ever wondered how restaurant chefs take cauliflower and turn it into “steaks?” It’s easy, and in this post I’ll show you how! I’ll also serve up a protein-rich, vegetarian recipe for Cauliflower Steaks with White Beans that you and your kids will LOVE.  It may seem complicated, but with a cutting board, a [more]

Food & Nutrition Adventures in Atlanta at FNCE 2014

Liz and I both attended the annual Food & Nutrition Conference & Expo (FNCE) of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics in Atlanta earlier this month, and we dish about our experiences on this week’s Cooking with the Moms podcast. Liz shared the highlights of her trip in an earlier blog post, and now it’s [more]

How to Make a Halloween Vegetable Skeleton + a Recipe for Rainbow Vegetable Dip

Vegetable Skeleton for Halloween via MealMakeoverMoms.com/kitchen #Halloween #Vegetable #skeleton #dip

For a healthy classroom or party treat, create a Halloween skeleton made with crunchy vegetables, and serve it with our Rainbow Vegetable Dip. And then watch the kids eat lots and lots of vegetables!  Why serve Halloween candy in the classroom or at a pre trick-or-treat party when the kids can munch and crunch their [more]

Food & Nutrition Trends and Adventures at FNCE 2014

FNCE Wrap Up via MealMakeoverMoms.com/kitchen

It’s been one week since my return from the Food & Nutrition Conference & Expo (FNCE) in Atlanta, and I’m still trying to dig my way out from under a GIANT pile of unread emails. (Some things never change!) My conference began with a food photography workshop for dietitians that I helped teach. You can [more]

Tips for Editing Beautiful Food Photos on Your Smart Phone (Part 2)

How to Edit Food Photos on Your Smart Phone via @MealMakeoverMoms.com/kitchen #Snapseed #Smartphonography

I have a lot of apps on my iPhone 5s, but the one I turn to the most is Snapseed, a fun photo editing app that I use to improve my food photos. This app crops, straightens, brightens, saturates, adjusts the white balance, and a whole lot more. It turns my food photos from drab to delicious [more]

Tips for Taking Beautiful Food Photos with Your Smart Phone (Part 1)

Smart Phone Food Photography Tips via MealMakeoverMoms.com/kitchen

As a registered dietitian nutritionist (RDN), I’ve always believed that if you want consumers to eat a healthy diet, you have to give them easy and affordable recipes that work, taste great, and look amazing and appetizing. This is a gorgeous image of our Homemade Healthy Beefaroni made with lean ground beef, mushrooms and red [more]